Classic Potato Salad Recipe

There’s something undeniably nostalgic and comforting about a bowl of Classic Potato Salad. It’s that dish everyone looks for at picnics and backyard BBQs — creamy, tangy, and studded with crunchy veggies and tender chunks of potato. This recipe is my go-to version after years of tweaking; it balances everything I love about the traditional style and always gets rave reviews. Whether you’re whipping it up for a special gathering or just craving a taste of summertime, this Classic Potato Salad is bound to be the star of your table!

Ingredients You’ll Need

With just a handful of kitchen staples, you can create this surprisingly flavorful salad. Each ingredient is carefully chosen to give Classic Potato Salad its irresistible contrast of creamy, crunchy, and tangy in every bite.

• Red potatoes: These hold their shape well and add a lovely color while staying creamy inside.
• Hard boiled eggs: They give richness and a classic touch that makes the salad extra satisfying.
• Celery: Adds a fresh crunch and a pop of green for a little brightness.
• Onion: Finely chopped, it brings a gentle bite and depth of flavor without overpowering.
• Mayonnaise: The creamy base that ties everything together; use your favorite brand for best results.
• Milk: Just enough to lighten the mayo and make the dressing ultra-silky.
• Yellow mustard: The secret to the salad’s signature tang and sunny yellow hue.
• Sugar: A pinch balances the acidity and brings out the flavors in the dressing.
• Salt: Seasoning the potatoes well is the key to their full flavor.
• Black pepper: Adds a little warmth and contrast to the creaminess.

How to Make Classic Potato Salad

Step 1: Boil the Potatoes

Start by placing the red potatoes in a large pot and cover them with about two inches of cold water. This helps the potatoes cook evenly from the outside in and prevents unwanted mushiness. Bring to a boil, then let them bubble away for about 15 minutes until you can slide a fork in with little resistance. Be careful not to overcook; the goal is perfectly tender bites that hold their shape.

Step 2: Cool and Peel the Potatoes

Once your potatoes are fork-tender, it’s time to give them a chill-down. Run them under cold water — this not only stops the cooking but makes peeling a breeze. If you love the earthy flavor and pop of color, feel free to leave the skins on, but peeling creates that classic, ultra-creamy texture. Let them cool to room temperature before moving on; warm potatoes can soak up too much dressing and turn mushy.

Step 3: Mix the Dressing

While the potatoes cool, whisk together the mayonnaise, milk, yellow mustard, sugar, salt, and black pepper in a small bowl. When mixing, taste as you go — some like a little more mustard zing, while others prefer a sweeter finish. The dressing should be creamy but pourable, with a beautiful pale yellow shade that screams Classic Potato Salad.

Step 4: Combine Potatoes and Veggies

Dice the cooled potatoes into bite-sized chunks and add them to a big mixing bowl. Chop the hard boiled eggs, celery, and onion, then toss them in as well. Pour the dressing all over, and gently fold everything together until every morsel is evenly coated. Mixing softly keeps your potatoes intact for those satisfying, hearty bites.

Step 5: Chill and Serve

Give the salad a taste and add a bit more salt or pepper if you like. Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and let it chill in the fridge for at least an hour. This resting time lets the flavors marry together, making the Classic Potato Salad taste even better when you finally dig in!

How to Serve Classic Potato Salad

Garnishes

For that classic finishing touch, sprinkle a little paprika or chopped fresh parsley over the top before serving. Sometimes a few extra egg slices or a scattering of green onions makes it look beautifully inviting. These garnishes not only offer color and a bit of flair, but also a subtle boost of flavor.

Side Dishes

Classic Potato Salad shines on its own but really sings beside grilled burgers, hot dogs, barbecue chicken, or even a simple ham sandwich. It’s also a fantastic companion to grilled corn, baked beans, and other favorite cookout staples. Try it with a crisp, tangy slaw or alongside some juicy watermelon for a truly memorable spread.

Creative Ways to Present

Level up the presentation by serving Classic Potato Salad in lettuce cups, mason jars for portable potlucks, or even as bite-sized canapés atop cracker rounds for a fun appetizer. If you’re feeling fancy, use a piping bag to swirl the salad into little mounds — it’s a playful way to impress guests while keeping the flavors familiar.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Leftover Classic Potato Salad is one of life’s simple joys. Store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator, and it will stay fresh and delicious for up to 3–4 days. The flavors tend to meld even more overnight, which many say makes the salad taste better the next day!

Freezing

I wouldn’t recommend freezing Classic Potato Salad, as the mayonnaise-based dressing and potatoes can change in texture after thawing. The salad often becomes watery and the veggies lose their crunch, so it’s best enjoyed fresh from the fridge.

Reheating

Potato salad is meant to be served cold or at room temperature, so there’s no need to reheat. If you do need to take the chill off, just let it sit out for about 20–30 minutes before serving, but always keep food safety in mind and don’t let it linger out in the heat for too long.

FAQs

Can I use a different type of potato?

Absolutely! While red potatoes offer a wonderful, waxy texture, Yukon Golds are a great alternative for a buttery flavor, and even Russets work if you prefer a fluffier salad. Just remember, different potatoes will affect how well the salad holds together.

Is there a way to make Classic Potato Salad lighter?

Yes! You can swap out half (or all) of the mayo for Greek yogurt or light mayonnaise to cut the calories while still keeping it creamy and tangy. Adjust seasonings to taste, since yogurt is a bit tangier than mayo.

How far ahead can I make potato salad?

You can prep Classic Potato Salad up to two days before you plan to serve it. In fact, the flavors will deepen and come together beautifully. Just give it a gentle stir before serving and refresh with a dash of salt or pepper if needed.

Can I add other ingredients?

Of course! Classic Potato Salad is endlessly customizable. Try tossing in chopped pickles, a scoop of relish, or a handful of crispy bacon. Even a dash of hot sauce in the dressing can offer a welcome kick. Have fun playing with your favorites!

What if my salad turns out too dry or too wet?

If the salad seems a bit dry, sprinkle in a touch more milk or mayo and mix gently. Too wet? Add a few extra potatoes or hard boiled eggs to soak up the excess. Classic Potato Salad is pretty forgiving, so make adjustments until it’s just right for you.

Final Thoughts

This recipe is everything I love about summer gatherings and good company: easy, comforting, and always in demand. I hope you make Classic Potato Salad a staple at your table, whether for bustling family picnics or simple weeknight dinners. Give it a try — you’ll soon see why it’s such a timeless favorite!

Print